Is it just me, or is the NBA All-Star Game just stale and boring these days?
Back in the earlier games, NBA All-Star games were competitive and the players seemed motivated to try and win. You had the ’93 game in Salt Lake City which went to overtime; Jordan getting a triple double in Cleveland – the guys genuinely wanted to be there to represent their conference and compete to win.
Nowadays, the players seem to display a great deal of apathy during the game, as if they’re there just to go through the motions. Yes the games are extremely high scoring so there is that, and I suppose you shouldn’t expect to see a great deal of defense during the game, but there doesn’t seem to be a great deal of incentive for these guys to actually compete in this game.
Lets be honest – most of the guys competing in the game are on huge money contracts. For example, Kyle Lowry is due to make $12 million this year, and Klay Thompson is contracted for just a bit over $3 million this season. I could list the entire East and West squad’s incomes, but you get the picture.
By comparison, the prize money awarded for the All-Star game is as follows: Each member of the winning team receives $50,000 and each member of the losing team receives $25,000. I’m not sure about you, but even if I was a member of the losing team, my mortgage payments for the year would be sorted, or I could pay off my car loan or buy a new car or go on a great holiday – whatever I wanted right? But if you take that prize money as a fraction or percentage of their yearly earnings, the players have very little incentive to win or lose. To earn $12,025,000 or $12,050,000 Kyle Lowry? Does it really matter?
You also have to consider the health of the players and the risk of injury. No one wants to see any of the NBA’s biggest names miss any games due to injury, and certainly not an injury stemming from a showcase event such as the NBA All Star game. Coaches, owners and the like would throw a fit if that were to happen (sure, the players would be insured, but a potential championship window could close with the tweak of a knee or shoulder or something (see Paul George and Team USA scrimmage for a great example).
So the players stand to make pocket change for competing in the game; they’re out there because fans or coaches voted them in, so there is a debt owing to those people to show face and your talents; and you’re also mindful of not over-exerting yourself as your team is in playoff contention and is a serious championship threat – how do you make the game more appealing?
A few schools of thought on the matter:
- Don’t hold the game mid-season – OK, the players not selected get a vacation of sorts during “All-Star break”, but if the game is held in the post/pre season, playoff contention isn’t a thought at this point. The Stars get a chance to condition themselves by playing against the best, so the competitiveness should be on display.
- Don’t award prize money if it’s not proportionate to the players’ earnings – Either front up a larger pay day for the guys (and have a bigger difference between winning and losing), or change up what the guys are playing for. In Major League Baseball, the conference who wins the All-Star game gets home ground advantage during the playoffs. Now that’s incentive. Don’t get me wrong, I don’t think the NBA should copy this – but give the players a greater purpose to compete.
- Don’t let the fans vote – This is echoing the sentiment of many commentators, but the fan vote tends to ignore current efforts and focuses in more on name recognition. Kobe Bryant – he’s one of the all-time great guards of the league; 3rd all-time in scoring and a 5-time NBA champion (among other achievements); no one is going to deny his right to one day be in the Basketball Hall of Fame. That being said, he and his team are not having a great year and he’s also sidelined with injury for the rest of the year. Compare that to Klay Thompson, Damian Lillard, Chris Paul and Russell Westbrook and try to explain how his season to date is better than those players, yet on popularity and name recognition alone, Bryant made the starting lineup. This is not new – for years Yao Ming was the starting centre for the West whilst his performance may not have warranted it in front of Shaq, Tim Duncan and Co. However, the overseas voting always made sure he was voted in.
It’s not a perfect system and it’s not too late to change the formula, but given the amount of money people pay to see this event (either live in person, via NBA league pass or by cable/pay TV), we the fans deserve better than the stale product being given to us now. Please also note that I have not touched on the other parts of the All-Star weekend (the Dunk competition also needs a serious overhaul), but as a fan, I just want to see the best rewarded for the efforts by being able to freely compete in this showcase event without feeling like their going through the motions.
Please, for us, move with the times.